Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The striking thing to me about this is that is is purportedly a "mechanical keyboard" and yet it failed after only 5 years.

I have purchased, or somehow gotten, at least 15 mechanical keyboards (and 10+ membrane-or-whatever keyboards) over the past 25 years.

Most of the cheap rubber-membrane-or-whatever keyboards failed within a few years, although there are some that kept on working.

But none of the mechanical ones did: Apple Extended Keyboard II (two of them) lasted 20+ years, IBM Model M, Unicomp Model M clone, Das Keyboard somethin something with Cherry MX blue/brown, 3 or 4 chinese knockoffs with cherry knockoff switches, two or three Mattias mechanical keyboards, 4 Filcos, 3 Code Keyboards (the WASM + Jeff Atwood venture) a couple Japanese hackety hacker boards... plus like 5-10 more at least.

None of them ever failed. I gave them away or whatever eventually but probably the average time span of which I was aware of them being in use is 15+ years.

So what Amazon may have innovated here is a mechanical keyboard that can fail as fast as the new rubber membrane inferior crap that came later?




Nothing in the article indicated that this is a mechanical keyboard.

This is some generic rubber-dome over membrane keyboard.


Oops, you are right! I re-read it, and... not sure where I got that impression from.

So, Amazon made a status quo membrane keyboard. OK, uh, then yeah I guess I'll just move on then.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: