Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The three words that can save your life (bbc.co.uk)
12 points by anthonysterling on Aug 15, 2019 | hide | past | favorite | 11 comments



An open-sourced anatidae-based alternative : what3ducks.com

Honestly I'm a bit annoyed by this article because it looks like an ad since it's a private commercial system.


Until a few weeks ago I've never heard before of 3words, but they seems to be online from a very long time.

Another similar geo location system, if I'm not wrong created by Google but released with a liberal license (Apache) and not patent encumbered, is called "plus.codes".

Edit: according to Wikipedia they were founded in 2013, don't recall why I thought they were older...


That's nice to learn about this alternative.

I haven't worked a lot with geolocation yet. But I'm driven to it because of my geography background, and I would be mad if every service for that kind of work was closed and proprietary.


It has to be an add, if they could download the app they surely could've sent their location to someone


Alternatively, give 911 the power to read out your gps location (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/112_(emergency_telephone_numbe..., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Mobile_Location)

Works when you aren’t able to talk (clearly) or when you can’t look at the screen (injury, screen broken).

Disadvantage: location information will be less precise.



if you have internet signal why not just share from google maps to sms?

On second thoughts, how do you even? I know I've done it before, but doing anything in google maps always takes me 15 minutes of searching howtos - just awful UI.

oh, you have to drop a pin first, and then share that. It seems like 'share my current location', without turning on tracking for an hour or whatever, would be a fairly obvious use-case.


So, people have to download an app because the UK emergency system is too broken to receive the GPS data directly from the phone.

+10 to dispatchers for a clever hack. -100 to governments for an emergency dispatch system that fails to actually be an emergency dispatch system.

In addition, what3words is copyrighted and patented and doesn't have a published standard.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Mobile_Location#Histo...:

”AML was developed in the United Kingdom by British Telecom, EE Limited, and HTC as a solution to problematic caller location in emergencies. When a person in distress calls the emergency services with a smart-phone where AML is enabled, the telephone automatically activates its location service to establish its position and sends this information to the emergency services via an SMS.[3] The services uses either a global navigation satellite system or WiFi depending on which one is better at the given moment”

This works, will shortly be required in the EU, but requires changes to your phone’s software and a change in the law (implicitly sharing your location is a privacy invasion)

It also still may be less accurate than you putting a marker on the map (but then, how good are people in distress in placing such a marker?)


That's a really cool concept. I like it.


However it seems to be completely under commercial/private control. Source: read the previous discussions at HN.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: