Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How about a background check and a mental check? Gun owners always call it a mental health crisis, so let's make sure all new gun owners are vetted and have to pass a psychological exam.



> How about a background check and a mental check?

That would pretty much guarantee that people who need mental health services would deliberately avoid getting it to prevent it from showing up on their records, e.g. a security guard who needs to carry a firearm for their job.


It gets worse. If you’re flagged with a mental illness, most states will yank your professional license (you lose your job and possible primary income). Our society has an economic incentive to underreport mental illness.


It would not be optional to do the mental exam.


> It would not be optional to do the mental exam.

Uh, what do you think a psychiatric exam is? There's no crazy-o-meter that they stick into an orifice to objectively determine whether you're mentally ill or not. You simply get asked a series of questions which you can reply to in any way you like.


How do you define a "mental check"?

"socially awkward people aren't allowed to have guns" as a policy would be a flagrant violation of a constitutional right.

The scary thing is that mentally ill people can intentionally mask their illness in order to pass exams.


Replying to the other comments under this reply: in Canada we check for past history of mental illness but don’t flag gun license applicants just because of that. They need to have a history of being treated due to illness that could lead to violence.


In the interests of keeping things pari passu, how about implementing mental screenings as part of voter registration as well?




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: