Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My first thought is wondering what data FB hopes to acquire from making this tool available.



FB is far from the only big tech company which has sponsored OSM as a competitor to Google Maps (Microsoft/Facebook/DigitalGlobe/Telenav/FourSquare/Craigslist have all sponsored OSM to some degree; Apple, of course, went its own way and created Apple Maps).

It's a reaction to Google Maps: a monopoly on high-quality up-to-date global maps with business location is dangerous to everyone else, as a chokepoint on mobile applications. It's less about 'acquiring data' and more about not being extorted by GM. Classic 'commoditize your complement' dynamics: https://www.gwern.net/Complement


Yes, see also "Corporate Editors in the Evolving Landscape of OpenStreetMap" https://www.mdpi.com/2220-9964/8/5/232/htm

Figure 3 demonstrates the scale of corporate OSM edits.


Apple Maps is based on OpenStreetMap, and they use OSM in many countries. I believe they use OSM for turn-by-turn routing in Denmark (or was it Netherlands) (source: Apple gave a talk at the OSM conference (SotM) in 2018, but required it not be recorded).


Their motivation is self-serving but I don't think it's so nefarious. They use OpenStreetMap in check-in posts to display map data around locations that Facebook users have visited, so improving OpenStreetMap in turn improves the quality of this feature.


Training data from OSM volunteers, at the very least. Probably both cheaper and higher quality than e.g. mechanical turk.


Cheaper location data than they'd get licencing one of the other map providers.


They want to be seen to be doing something with computer vision/AI.


User location data is useless without the substrate of a proper map.


exactly my thought as well.

Whenever Facebook releases something we should all directly worry about what their real motives are.


They need good quality maps.

I worry that they'll try to embrace and extend in some way.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: