Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I have a couple questions which don't seem to be answered on the website if anyone knows the answers.

1. Is the battery a rechargeable or normal battery that I have to replace?

2. Can I easily download my sleep data to my computer to mess around with?



1. Rechargeable. Lasts about 2-3 nights depending on how long you sleep.

2. Not yet.


The FAQ on the web site currently says 6 nights. Might want to update that.


Could you elaborate as to why it's only 2-3 nights of battery life? I'd expect much more from something like this.


Wakemate uses bluetooth, doesn't it? Thats bound to eat up power.


Bluetooth shouldn't ever be on except for when it needs to upload sleep data to your phone though (which I assume is done right when waking up).


That's putting a lot of stock into the device itself.

Conjecture: I think it's more likely that the device is something of an accelerometer paired with a bluetooth radio that can nearly continuously feed the phone/app with movement data so that the app can decide whether or not to rouse you.

Rationale: The algorithm. Assuming they want to tweak their actigraphy parameters, if the algorithm is running on the wristband you're going to need to drop new firmware on the device. Field-flashing embedded devices is to be avoided at all reasonable costs.


Field-flashing isn't that bad as long as it can safely be done over bluetooth, and I'd be willing to take that risk to have reasonable battery life.


So, again, I don't know anything about the device in question, so this is all conjecture... but:

Even given that OTA flashing is possible, why bother? The device has no means of waking the user without a phone in bluetooth range, so what's the upshot? I don't know that battery life falls into that category because the device would need some pretty serious upgrades, and cost would obviously increase:

- More RAM. Lots more. Enough to contain an entire firmware image during OTA and an entire night of sleep/movement history.

- More MIPS. Actigraphy isn't going to be as cheap as store-and-forward.

- A reliable RTC so that the device can ping the phone at the right wakeup time.

- etc.

If I was in their position, I'd build the device to be as dumb a peripheral as possible. Push the complexity out of expensive hardware and into software. I'd also probably have built in a sweet inductive charging pad, too, but I'm a sucker for shiny things.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: