Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Research into the reasons for trepanation (2016) (bbc.com)
16 points by clouddrover on June 17, 2019 | hide | past | favorite | 9 comments


If you're interested in trepanation, there's a fascinating documentary from the late 90s called 'A Hole in the Head' about people performing self-trepanation. Cooky for sure but I've been fascinated ever since. It has made me wonder what percentage of ancient trepanations were done purely for the mysticism of piercing something which shouldn't be pierced.


In 500 years lobotomy devices will be rediscovered by some scholar, or many other psychiatry procedures that are performed up to date, as rituals.

Drilling someone's mind seems to be a common theme among societies.

Thousands of years of evolution to end up making something like that a part of the science corpus. Discouraging.


ECT as well, while you mention it.


Well, at the very least electroconvulsive therapy is proven to be effective in psychoses, while lobotomy has no added benefits. ECT will (or so I hope) be replaced in the future but maybe not by something fundamentally different - just more easily palatable.


There is the problem of pre-history and people not writing stuff down. So the topic is always going to be open to interpretation.

People in the 60's did the hole in the head to get high - more oxygen to the brain. Not everyone but a few people. It could have been a thing like that fashion a few years ago with people getting their tongues split in two - detestable as a thought for most people but with some people who get into it.

I thought that there were also necklaces with the bone discs, not seen any stories of that recently.


>People in the 60's did the hole in the head to get high - more oxygen to the brain. Not everyone but a few people

Do you have any sources for that? It's the the first time I've heard of such a thing. Not doubting you, just curious to learn more.


here's an account of one person who've done this: https://news.bme.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/pubring/peop... Not for the faint of heart


> People in the 60's did the hole in the head to get high - more oxygen to the brain.

Wouldn't that be like stuffing your chest cavity with food to give your stomach more nutrients?


I don't think the idea is to expose the brain to air, but to increase blood-flow to the brain.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: