On: BeGoneAds – A Python script that blocks ads by installing common hosts files

[josteink]

Systemd has a cron system too.

I’m just guessing, but it might be easier to programmatically install a systemd cron job (and making sure it runs) than doing so for the old/conventional crond?

[gumby → josteink]

Just using cron is back compatible

[Spivak → gumby]

Things you get with systemd that you don't get with cron unless you implement them in the script.

* Not running if the network is down.

* Not running if the download path isn't available.

* Running if the machine was off during the scheduled time.

* Monitoring and retry logic.

* Logging to syslog.

* Resource constraints.

* Random wait.

It ends up being a lot of code factored out of the actual application.

[behringer → Spivak]

so instead of code in one place you have it in 2?

[JustSomeNobody → behringer]

I don’t understand this logic. Can you explain why having code in more than one place is a bad thing?

[behringer → JustSomeNobody]

For a simple script that does one thing, it's overkill.

[josteink → behringer]

Yes. So you keep that simple script simple, and you let systemd do the heavy lifting.

[behringer → josteink]

But systemd doesn't do any of the above listed things automatically... You'd need to write an entire script for sytstemd to take advantage of it. An entire script you could just have run with cron on boot.