Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There are plenty of non-spiral galaxies where we observe the same.

Our sun moving away from the galactic center is also unlikely as if it had been much further in during it's creation phase, it would have been unable to create planets that support life. A galactic year is only a few million earth years, so our orbit must have remained in the stable region for the first billion years or so and we continue to be inside it. That points to a stable orbit around the galaxy.

If it was a firework wheel our current position would mean that sun would have been traveling to the outside of the galaxy far below escape velocity or would have been unable to produce life-bearing planets.




>A galactic year is only a few million earth years

no. It is 250 million years.

>so our orbit must have remained in the stable region for the first billion years or so and we continue to be inside it.

not really. While moving on that spiral trajectory, we've made only 16 rotations since Sun's formation. When the life on our planet started our neighborhood looked very different, not the boonies we're at right now :)


>no. It is 250 million years.

I don't see how that contradicts is being a few million years?

>not really. While moving on that spiral trajectory, we've made only 16 rotations since Sun's formation. When the life on our planet started our neighborhood looked very different, not the boonies we're at right now :)

Orbits don't really do spiral patterns in practice. Atleast not at this scale. The star would either be in a fairly stable orbit or on trajectory to leave the galaxy (minus elliptical orbits but those would carry the sun in and out of the dead zone quite often).

Moving on a spiral trajectory does happen in orbital mechanics but only in one direction; inwards. Outwards spiraling would require quite a few quirks in the galactic gravity field.

The spiral pattern itself isn't the result of a firework wheel, it's quite a quirk in the distribution of stars, though there are various models that explain them, they all involve very stable orbits for most stars.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: