Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

“Sol” is the name of our star, not whatever star happens to be closest to a given planet.



So what? The name of those little points of light in the night sky isn't "stella", but they give off stellar radiation.

It's solar radiation by reference to the concept of the sun, not by reference to an entry in an astronomical catalog somewhere.


> The name of those little points of light in the night sky isn't "stella"

Well, yeah, the generic name for them is exactly that (well, in Latin, but that's also where Sol as the particular name for ours comes from.)


In terms of Latin, sol is just as generic as stella is. (Modulo the fact that there is only one sun.)

If you want to object that "Sol" is the name of an individual star, and that "solar radiation" is named after that name, in spite of the capitalization, rather than deriving from the Latin word, then you can't really make your arguments based on what the words mean in Latin.


> In terms of Latin, sol is just as generic as stella is. (With the caveat that there is only one sun.)

We can argue over whether the idea of a generic label for a class that by definition has exactly one member is coherent, but I don't think that's necessary: stars that aren't the sun are stella and aren't sol, whether you take the latter to mean “Aren't the single particular entity named ‘Sol'” or “Aren’t one of the members (of which there are exactly one) of the class whose members are designated ‘sol’”.

There's a reason they are “extra-solar planets” and not “other-solar planets”.


It was a class with one member at the time Latin was spoken. It's the same class now, but with many members.

Once you admit that the sun is an example of a star, "sun" becomes a deictic reference.

Note that "Sol" is not the English name of our sun. We call it "the Sun", at the same time that we're happy to say that planets in other stellar systems have suns of their own. "Sol" is a name internal to academic astronomy, much like the name "bufo bufo" for what are actually called "toads".


Great job guys, pedantically arguing over a word and missing the whole point of the article =)




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: