Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't think many of us on the main thread earlier this week did. Please explain why they still sell expensive Mathematica licenses if it is all now free (note that I'm not saying it isn't worth it). What are we missing?

Regardless, thanks for correcting my error!




Because of the "crazy" license (I would say it's quite reasonable, essentially it disallows using it for anything else than development or in the context of non-commercial personal projects), the user interface [1], the support... I don't use Mathematica myself, I don't know what functionality is missing.

[1] the free wolfram engine is a command line (or API) application and the Jupyter interface is much more primitive than the real thing: https://github.com/WolframResearch/WolframLanguageForJupyter


I would guess that over half of their current customers use Mathematica for development and prototyping (but don't put anything into production). This would effectively mean that they would let go of ~50% of their revenue over night (we're this to be true). So that line of thought is why I'm so confused. Does that make sense?


My impression was that they did it to gain new customers. People who didn't use it because they could only use it for prototyping but up to now weren't able to directly use their solution in production. Where production includes internal not-customer-facing tools, for example a custom UI or webpage for engineers or financial analysts where the backend calls into Mathematica as opposed to for example Python and its math libraries.


> up to now weren't able to directly use their solution in production.

That’s exactly what you __cannot__ do with their new “free wolfram engine for developers” license.


Thanks for pointing that out!

I hadn't followed the original discussion. I mistook the new license for a simplified runtime/production license. Looking at the announcement and the licensing terms again, I don't understand the benefit. At least, I don't feel more inclined to give it a try than I was before. (It's a great product but I still wouldn't base a project on it.)




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: