Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This makes no sense. Moving emphasis from Production (work) to Consumption (leisure) increases carbon usage, and halts progress towards more sustainable technologies and conservative behaviours. Climate progress takes effort not entertainment.


Why does leisure have to mean consumption? And isn't consumption necessarily limited to the amount produced?

I wasn't particularly impressed by TFA, but I don't understand this criticism of it.


Well, you still need to consume, eat, house yourself etc. Any situation where you're not paying for that without a productive output is one where you're increasing the ratio of consumption to production. Of course not all work is productive, but solving inefficiencies is _work_ not leisure


Most work isn't aimed at making technological progress towards a more ecological or otherwise better future.

Most work is also not aimed at food production or housing anymore because of technology.


A large proportion of work is aimed at housing, but for entirely the wrong reasons. Housing costs in first world countries these days generally expand to consume available income, via land price inflation. Actual build cost - "production" - is a minor piece of the pie.


Yeah, my leisure is running, meditation, hiking, playing guitar. Aside from driving to hike on occasion (or train), I don't consume more.


You don't drive to the mountain when you go for a hike or wear shoes when you go running?


You can do an awful lot of that before you start throwing off waste at even a fraction of the rate of a fast food restaurant or other small business.



That doesn't even begin to compare to commuting daily to bullshit jobs.


That's assuming all work is valuable (and productive). There are swaths of jobs that could be eliminated in favor of automation.

I think the most sustainable long term approach is to aim for efficiency. No need to have people commute to an admin job that could easily be done by software.

That being said, we need to also strive for sustainable consumption.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: