Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's a problem from an LP's POV. There is no reason to invest in a VC fund that returns 2x when you can invest in a Vanguard index fund that returns 2x. You're supposed to get compensated with higher returns for the risk you take investing in VC; if you don't, the managers of that fund are failing at their jobs.



> There is no reason to invest in a VC fund that returns 2x when you can invest in a Vanguard index fund that returns 2x.

That's not how it works. LPs create a portfolio mix across asset classes and each LP has generally different mixes based on their risk profile. If you're an LP and can't get into a Sequioa/Benchmark/etc fund but still want to diversify asset classes into VC then a "2x fund" might still be attractive to be able to diversify into. There's so much to unwind here, but long story - it's not that simple at all. I agree with the OP's assertion about Matt Levine's view.

Example: https://twitter.com/ZacharyDeWitt/status/1112554272929910785

Edit: Another point worth noting - hedge funds as an asset class are notoriously not outpacing index funds (and in many cases actually losing value), yet they still get funded: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/12/business/hedge-funds.html


I agree in theory but not in reality. But it's the same situation where the the incentives of an LP and a VC are different (not really that different compared to a PE or Hedge Fund). Just like the incentives of a founder and a VC are aligned, until they aren't anymore. There's a reason LPs with squillions to invest carve off a tiny smidge to VCs, and it's not just returns - it's also downside protection. What's true for you and me for our personal finance is not necessarily true for the Harvard endowment.


I thought it's because VC only had a smidge of capacity to absorb capital. You can't fit everyone's $10-$100B funds into VC projects.

Less then 1% of Facebook's value is VC funding.


That was a different era. Look at the latest crop of unicorns.


Not so much downside protection or even absolute return, but rather uncorrelated returns.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: