Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Ah come on, be fair. Every psychiatric disorder has a pretty high chance of getting resolved without any action from outside. Very few people actually succumb to them.

Furthermore, especially with psychiatric disorders, there is a high percentage of patients that aren't helped, but exactly the opposite, by treatment. That systematically get worse because of treatment.

(I do not claim this is easy or pleasant for the patient, merely that it happens. Furthermore in the more common cases where treatment makes the patient worse it is also incredibly unpleasant, unfair and entirely terrible for the patient)

(and of course you could correctly claim that this is even true for cancer, and it is. However for cancer the percentage of patients that get better without treatment is something like 0.2% up to 4% depending on the cancer, whereas for psychiatric disorders the amount of people that recover without treatment is easily > 90%)




Originally I posted a longer response, but it's not worth breaking down because the original content is complete, unfounded nonsense. It's the kind of thing you'd read on an anti vax facebook page.

No, the vast majority of those with psychiatric disorders do not recover without treatment

No, there is not a high percentage of patients that get worse because of treatment

Either a source needs to be posted or the comment should be deleted because it is completely false, not adding to the discussion, and incredibly dismissive of those experiencing psychiatric problems or seeking psychiatric treatment


Source for any of this? 90% is a number you should be getting from somewhere, and it sounds unbelievably high.


I would go even further and call it "dismissively" high.


Autism is not a "psychiatric" disorder, it is a developmental disorder with neurological and physiological symptoms.


I don’t think what you’re saying is accurate or appropriate for autism.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: