Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I haven't heard an anti-tax argument in this topic, but this is a main argument between economists and statists.

Economists will always say that the tax should be explicit, and it should be placed for the people that ultimately pay for it. But pro-taxes people, mainly the government, want higher revenues first, which means putting a tax wherever you can, and that is about what is politically feasible, not about what is economically sound.

The end result is a hybrid of both interests. For example, San Francisco charges sales taxes, known to be regressive and punishing to poor people, but at least you know you are paying them on a ticket. Other countries, like europe, hide the VAT taxes, so it looks like you are not paying taxes at all. VAT reaches 10~20%, sales taxes in SF is around 6%.

Making it explicity DEFINITELY reduces it.




> Other countries, like europe, hide the VAT taxes, so it looks like you are not paying taxes at all.

That is not true at all. In all European countries that I can think of you get to see the whole price, including VAT so that, you know, you can actually tell how much the product is going to cost you. The composition of that price is then shown, often in smaller font. This is true of price stickers, receipts and invoices.

I do not find it the least bit misleading, and would be rather annoyed if a cashier told me to pay more money than the price sticker indicates.


Parent did not say that it is misleading.

The claim was that the tax caused price increase is hidden in the overall price.

And while the reasons for that can be plentiful (even consumer protection, if wanted) one effect is certainly and obviously that it hides the amount of sales tax you pay.

The VAT is usually declared somewhere in the bill.


It is very misleading: do it the other way around and people would complain about the tax constnatly, which is what people do in the US and in Canada.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: