Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Show HN: Client Side Encrypted Backups – easy to use and no chance of corruption (github.com/scott-kaplan)
7 points by CloudBuddy on March 30, 2019 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments



This was the same argument made about RAID backups. You won't lose a backup as long as you replace the right hard drive.

It can still corrupt if the local storage is/goes bad.


Thanks for your comment. Actually, Client-Side-Encrypted-Backups is different in that a backup cannot be created unless tar, ccrypt and sftp on the user's machine execute smoothly. In your example, in the case of a user's local drive going bad during a backup, one of these (tar, ccrypt, sftp) would fail causing the backup to not be created. All files that show up in the completed_backups log file are golden backups and can be restored at anytime. For me, I have been exclusively using Client-Side-Encrypted-Backups to do all of my backups (since 2011). I don't ever recall seeing an issue in all of those years. It's been very reliable.


Why did you choose not to use rsync ? ( Also, you regarding the criticism you received: perhaps you are interested in using TAHOE-LAFS. )


So corrupt backups weren't possible - just my personal preference.


rsync can be applied as such. Either I don't understand you and am missing something or you could use the following link: https://linux.die.net/man/1/rsync Anyhow: Good stuf you're making && godspeed at your venture. ^_^


Thank you kind sir.

When I was investigating backup solutions in 2010, I did read about rsync and had read a few negative reviews saying that user's had their backups corrupted (by rsync) and that they were unable to restore their backups. However, looking now I am unable to find those reviews. So, likely either those issues were fixed in a newer version of rsync or I am not remembering the posts correctly.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: