On: Inheriting the Trauma of Genocide

[taneq]

You're conflating "financially successful" with "untraumatized". I'm not convinced that the first necessarily implies the second.

[jshevek → taneq]

I took his point to be that trauma doesn't determine outcome. Jews have been traumatized, but are successful. Thus the economic outcomes of other traumatized groups may be strongly influenced by factors other than trauma.