The problem is with the initial line of reasoning: "If you don't like x, don't do x". It's the biggest load of crap that everyone buys into for some reason. It's like saying if you don't like air pollution, move to a different location. Like yes, true, but also I want to improve the situation in my current location, not abandon it.
That's how people feel on the internet, and you're asking them to throw in the towel completely and accept they'll never be able to share anything on the internet in private. You're even going as far as to say if they want something private they shouldn't be doing it. Both of these two things are untrue, but especially the idea that technology is inherently un-private and can never be so.
> Both of these two things are untrue, but especially the idea that technology is inherently un-private and can never be so.
I'm sorry, but I think you need to start with a list of ways you think people can use technology which has a high degree of certainty of being and remaining private.
Because I can't think of any.
Credit cards are an abomination. ISPs and wireless carriers know way too much metadata. Every social media company is a horror show. The ability to uniquely identify your browser across sites is terrifying. NSA's Carnivore. Keyloggers. Zero day exploits in the OS, in the browser, etc. Row hammer. Spectre and Meltdown. Elemental Technologies. SMS authentication and account recovery. Every online store knows way too much.
So, can you list maybe one or two things in technology you think are strong-guarantee secure and private?
And I'm not saying to give up. This is the fight of our lives. But right now we've LOST. We need to think about how to start over, to try to win next time.
I think we thought of computers and the internet as our allies in privacy. They are not. They are our enemies.
I think we should stop trusting computers, any computers, as much as we possibly can.
Especially if you're in a minority that your government may try to punish.
---
We all deserve privacy, and we are all almost completely denied privacy, by design, by hundreds of systems we use daily.
I highly recommend the novels "Daemon" and "Freedom" by Daniel Suarez, which explore just how vulnerable our digital infrastructure is.