Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"What If Linus Torvalds Gets Hit by a Bus?” is now permanently archived on: https://setinblock.com/0x8006d703a45663cab96a85a4ef3e6ab94a1...



Do you have a license to permanently redistribute it?


That's not a traditional form of re-distribution. In legal terms, I guess it's a gray area.

The article is now on the blockchain. It is not published (re-distributed) anywhere in particular. It's also encoded and not in the actual form of an article.


Involving a technically convoluted mechanism doesn't change the fundamental legal question here. It's just made it harder for you to undo your potential violation.

A temporary web mirror has at least a narrow time scope and a justification. Choosing to embed a copy of content you don't own into a permanently-public record is a greater offense.


> Choosing to embed a copy of content you don't own into a permanently-public record is a greater offense.

Anybody making copies of that record, and anybody distributing them, would be (and probably already is) breaking the law.

But then, the one embedding it only broke the law once, by making and distributing one copy of the protected work, same as reposting it on a temporary web mirror. Worse, with a web mirror you make and distribute copies for every requests...


I wonder where exactly do you see the violation?

Is it that I archived it on the blockchain, or that I shared a reader link to that transaction where the article is archived?


> Crummy is © 1996-2018 Leonard Richardson. Unless otherwise noted, all text licensed under a Creative Commons License.

You're fine. I would not recommend doing this with texts which you dont have the copyright to.


Yes, I also saw this later.

But for better understanding, I would love to hear more about "embed a copy of content you don't own into a permanently-public record is a greater offense". What is this based on? Are there any known precedents?


Haha thats great!




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: