Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My bad; that's not my footnote. Please see the original post:

  * To see a Looking Glass demo, click here – it starts at the ~2:00 minute mark.



I remember the project Looking Glass.

It was one "few days work" demo somebody threw around when they first were able to manipulate windows in 3D in a compositor with Java, but it got traction in parts of the OSS blogosphere/forums as some revolutionary new desktop experience (even though there were already several similar commercial offerings, and itself was little more than some little-thought 3D manipulations and in no way an actual full SUN project).

It was touted as "SUN innovation" example, and predictably, it got nowhere.

Here it is in all its glory. Even then it was a derivative, no-sense concept: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1JwfgBv5bg

I've seen the same story play out several times.

E.g. there was a node.js based editor that was the talk of HN for a while. Got nowhere, was just a simple editing window + crude syntax highlighting, and it was obvious from the start that it wont go anywhere with its direction and chops, but not if you heard the gasps just because somebody powered an editor with Node:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2020673

Or the Lighttable editor -- itself being abandoned for the next shiny endeavor, which again makes sense as it was just some inline REPL touches on top of a crude editor. At least that explored the design space a little, but the promises where touting it as the next thing that will revolutionize programming...


The Lighttable Saga is def a sad one and occasionally kind of irritates me.

I have no idea of what "really happened", but my layman's interpretation of how that went down is...

- Make a great thing w potential.

- Kickstarter it.

- Rush to meet the KS deadline.

- Get frustrated. Abandon it.

- Take VC money to take "the next step" (Eve)

- Spend VC millions over X years, release some ideas in WIP repos, nothing holistic or truly practical.

- Fold.

- Then go to work for a proprietary Database Tools Vendor who will implicitly inherit any learning made during the previous projects.

Sadness and "loss" everywhere. If I was a VC in that early deal, I'd be pissed when Looker "finally releases" Eve as some middle-ware BI system.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: