Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Students digging into data archive spot mysterious X-ray source (esa.int)
58 points by sohkamyung on Aug 11, 2018 | hide | past | favorite | 10 comments


“This event is challenging our understanding of X-ray outbursts: too short to be an ordinary stellar flare, but too faint to be linked to a compact object,” explains collaborator Sandro Mereghetti, lead author of the paper presenting the results.

Another possibility is that the source is a so-called chromospherically active binary, a dual system of stars with intense X-ray activity caused by processes in their chromosphere, an intermediate layer in a star’s atmosphere. But even in this case, it does not closely match the properties of any known object of this class.

Interesting. I guess an alien source was ruled out due to magnitude of the source. Still, would be interesting to see if there is potentially an underlying communication pattern there.


I’d imagine they ruled out an alien source simply because any astronomical phenomenon could be produced by aliens. Thinking about that for anything slightly unusual is just burdensome cognitive overhead.

Similar to how cosmologists aren’t satisfied with “god did it” as an explanation. :)


Is there a reason they don't print the high school students' names? It seems like they should be given some sort of credit for their work.


The student names are in the acknowledgement section of the paper.

https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2018/08/aa33086-...


You can find their names at the end of the article. Hope this guys will keep working in the field in the future.


Ah, you're right -- the "continue" button shows them. Never mind!


But on a journalistic note, isn’t it proper form for names to be above the fold? Maybe scientific journalism is different?


It doesn't appear that the high school students are authors on the paper. Academic papers place authors at the top of the paper (some exceptions for e.g. huge collaborations with hundreds of authors) and acknowledgments at the end of the paper. It appears the article follows this pattern, so I don't find it at all "offensive" coming from an academic background; simply different conventions of where names appear, but they are listed.


They are probably still minors, where laws get pretty odd around identity.


> laws get pretty odd around identity.

I mean, their photographs are right in the middle of the article. Besides, the names of students are in the acknowledgment section of the paper.

https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2018/08/aa33086-...




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: