> To summarize, it seems like they made some mistakes, microed their services in a knee-jerk attempt to alleviate the symptoms of the mistakes, realized microservices didn't fix their mistakes, finally addressed the mistakes, then wrote a blog post about microservices.
You try to remove the critique from microservices, but for me these issues are actually good arguments against microservices. It's hard to do right.
It is weird that they took on some problems so easy. Shared libraries is one point. To get them right for hundreds slightly different services is something I don't even want to think about. The only strategy I can come up with is to maintain them as if they're a 3rd party lib and cannot contain business logic. So you're forced to build solutions around them and not with them.
Then there have been quite a few warnings to not use shared code in microservices.
This was exactly my thought! Despite all the hoohah around the decisions made and whether or not they did things correctly, this idea of "we'll create a bunch of separate services and then use a common shared library for all/most of them" was the start of the end from where I'm sitting... doing this is exactly where the trouble starts with future code changes as the shared library almost becomes a god-like object amongst the services using it: change something in the shared lib and all services using it need to be re-tested. Unless proper versioning takes place, but that, from my experience, seems to rarely be the case. Or need proper service ownership and chain or notification to inform service owners when particular versions are being deprecated or retired... which seems to rarely be the case as well.
Even so, imagine the chaos if frequently engineers/devs need to add code to one lib(the shared one), wait for PR approval, then use that new version in a different lib to implement the actual change that was needed? Thats seems to be introducing a direct delay into getting anything productively done...
You try to remove the critique from microservices, but for me these issues are actually good arguments against microservices. It's hard to do right.