Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The first hand account is the former Israeli NCO paratrooper

The worst paratrooper they ever had, per their own admission.

The US does not train the same way Israel does. Which does not train the same way China does, or Germany does, and so on.




>The worst paratrooper they ever had, per their own admission.

Because he wasn't suited to military style leadership. So he became a software dev instead, and he enjoyed that much more.

Still, this is a fair point.

>The US does not train the same way Israel does. Which does not train the same way China does, or Germany does, and so on.

The IDF is, as I said above, famous for its individualism and relatively lax standards of discipline by Western military standards. I suppose having fought several huge wars of national survival within living memory makes you throw all the superfluous authoritarianism out the window and retain only those parts of it which are essential to function.

So if even they are still very heavy on authority and instant obedience, the US isn't going to be any better. Nor, especially, would China who follow the Russian school of top-down control compared to the Western emphasis on bottom up (aka mission-style tactics the other fellow linked to).




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: