Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

ask the fsf? I'm pretty sure that I've read they have people that will help you.

But I think it's the other way... you couldn't write a proprietary app based on a gpl library.

Look at all the 'open source' apps based on .NET and other windows technologyies.

I my self don't believe such apps are truly open source, as they rely on non open code.

"The standard disclaimer applies, I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice."



I think there's an exception that says that OS libraries don't count, since that would mean that you could not write open-source software on any commercial OS.

I had a difficult time figuring this out when I released a plugin for the closed-source software LCDC under the GPL. While it's clear that you can't link a GPL library into a non-GPL executable, the reverse case seems to be more muddy. I finally settled to my satisfaction that the spirit of the GPL should not prevent me from open-sourcing a library even if that library only is meaningful when used with a closed-source executable, given that I as the copyright holder can state the intent that the library be linked with proprietary software. It's sort of like the proprietary software is my "OS" and I'm linking to it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: