> The bill also requires companies to offer people the same communications services whether or not they agree to have their data collected
Again with this madness. Please convince me how this does not violate the right of people to come into contracts with each other? The internet is not a private space as the EU's lawmakers seem to want it to be, but a public space like the real world. If you want privacy, you buy a house, and similarly you get a subscription service online. I appreciate that everyone is sensitive with their privacy these months, but please try to be rational. FWIW, as an EU citizen i am sometimes offended by the stupidity of our lawmakers.
This is not madness. Many (if not all) EU countries have a law that regulates contracts. One principle is that the one in the weaker position in the contract should have some protections.
This can be seen as an extension to such a law.
It appears that consumers are in the weaker position in the contract here because major ISP can in (silent) agreement to refuse to provide a fair contracts. For example they are in such position because majority of consumers do not care.
In europe ISPs dont have monopolies. Thats legitimate - the government should interfere to make sure there are options. This doesnt make the law right though because then
> they are in such position because majority of consumers do not care
is like stating that users are idiots that need a nanny state.
Difference is that in a public space in the real world you clearly and easily recognize what is happening around you. On the internet, you are being ripped off without even noticing thanks to UX that is optimized by companies to get what they want – not what is good for you, the user.
Sure, put a sign "We are tracking you" on the page header in bold red. I'm all for transparency. Now you know that when you enter the space you 're tracked. Why are you able to demand that it's turned off?
Again with this madness. Please convince me how this does not violate the right of people to come into contracts with each other? The internet is not a private space as the EU's lawmakers seem to want it to be, but a public space like the real world. If you want privacy, you buy a house, and similarly you get a subscription service online. I appreciate that everyone is sensitive with their privacy these months, but please try to be rational. FWIW, as an EU citizen i am sometimes offended by the stupidity of our lawmakers.