Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
EPA chief signs proposal limiting science used in decisions (apnews.com)
9 points by clumsysmurf on April 24, 2018 | hide | past | favorite | 4 comments



The hypocrisy would mind-boggling if it weren't such an established pattern of twisting good words to cover evil deeds, a la the infamous "PATRIOT Act". No demands to open up data generated by government-funded science, no efforts to build privacy-respectful reliable data sets, just suppressing inconvenient truths.


A rather slanted headline!

The article later states:

"increase transparency in the agency’s decision-making by requiring all underlying data used in scientific studies to be made publicly available"

That sure sounds like a good thing. It would of course limit the use of data that is unreproducible due to being kept secret, but that isn't bad at all.


It’s in the second paragraph. This article is spun so hard it’s headed out to sea. I’m as down for a ride on the current administration hate train as the next guy, but how is this a bad thing?


"the change, long sought by chemical manufacturers and fossil fuel companies"

"designed to restrict the agency from citing peer-reviewed public-health studies that use patient medical records that must be kept confidential under patient privacy laws."

and the next paragraph:

"Such studies include the Harvard School of Public Health’s landmark Six Cities study of 1993, which established links between death rates and dirty air in major U.S. cities. That study was used by EPA to justify tighter air-quality rules opposed by industrial polluters."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: