Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How is the country/continent of origin of a regulation that is entirely in your best interest of any relevance?



> How is the country/continent of origin of a regulation that is entirely in your best interest of any relevance?

Laws carry their culture. GDPR is, from an American perspective, an overworked mess designed to support a big bureaucracy. This side of the Atlantic, we'd do something slimmer, more reliant on privately-funded cases (and regulatory complaints) versus public ombudsmen, and better attuned to start-ups’ needs.


Indeed. A law is just a text in a hierachy of norms, and so is this text. Accordingly, its weight may vary from country to country in the EU, first because the relationship between the Constitution of a country and the EU norms may not be the same. Moreover, one should not forget that enforcing a law requires a whole judicial system, and once again, this judicial system may vary from country to country in the EU. Think of the GDPR as a program : it runs with some privileges in a given software context and requires some hardware ressources to run.

IMHO, as an EU citizen, an American perspective would be welcome. A text must fit the local hierarchy of norms and the local judicial system.

You may read this article related to this point of view : https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21739961-gdprs-premis...


This correctly represents my feelings about it.


How many pages are there in your tax code?


>a regulation that is entirely in your best interest

doesn't exist




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: