The other user who replied on this thread saiya-jin is [dead] and has been so for over a month. Their comments appear to be entirely reasonable to me, can we un-dead them?
You can un-dead individual comments yourself by clicking the time of the comment, then clicking "vouch". I think the mods see that and can choose to do more significant un-deading (what a fun verb!).
EDIT: User is visible again, thanks.