Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

A fallen tree in damp conditions rots down in a year or so. Seems pretty biodegradable.

Your second sentence I have no problem with.




Yeah, "decent care" means "kept away from moisture, fire, and bugs."

Such care can be difficult in the long term, but yields results like the beautiful 700 year-old woodwork in this English cathedral. (And of course the comments mention the Buddhist temple Hōryū-ji.)

http://blog.longnow.org/02009/01/12/how-long-can-wood-last/


I agree completely. The only part I disagree with its the claim wood is "barely biodegradable". Almost anything can be preserved.


If we're disregarding proper maintenance, almost anything can be biodegradable too. Steel will easily rust into dust in an alarmingly short period of time, but we have 100-story buildings made of un-rusted steel lasting for a century and maybe centuries more. Compared to cars from 5 years ago rusted into oblivion even while they're still being driven.


Rusting isn't biodegrading, it's chemical. Of course the lines aren't distinct, but they seem much clearer than you're suggesting.


In this case I don't think it really matters. No one says "my car is fine, it's just rusting not biodegrading". What matters is that the car is disappearing right before your eyes through natural processes that could have been prevented with normal maintenance.

Wood, when properly taken care of, lasts forever. Steel, when properly taken care of, lasts forever. Each of them will degrade without proper maintenance, and oddly enough they both have basically the same maintenance needs. Keep them dry, otherwise oil them occasionally.


If you mean ‘rot away’, then your statement is not true at all. Trees take a long time to rot away. If you meant ‘start to rot’, then yes, you’re right. https://www.google.com/search?q=how+long+does+it+take+a+tree...

Google says minimum 50 years.


Well, that can be seen as a feature as well. When it's no longer useful and left to its own devices, it will disappear all by itself rather than leaving a pile of toxic waste that someone else has to worry about.


a fallen tree will also easily get overrun by bugs and animals and does not have a closed surface, making it prone to rot


Isn't that biodegrading? Surely almost anything can be cared for to prevent biodegrading.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: