Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
How Facebook Figures Out Everyone You've Ever Met (gizmodo.com)
38 points by uptown on Nov 14, 2017 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments


This is a creepy thing to be in possession of a profit driven public company.


" Behind the Facebook profile you’ve built for yourself is another one, a shadow profile, built from the inboxes and smartphones of other Facebook users. Contact information you’ve never given the network gets associated with your account, making it easier for Facebook to more completely map your social connections. "

Careful sharing your addressbooks... you may have non-personal (friends) contacts in there you may not wish Facebook to link to your profile and "People You May Know" suggestions


Is there really no legal option to stop this? Can't users who don't use facebook file a restraining order?


From the article (emphasis mine): > It doesn’t like the term [shadow profile] because it sounds like Facebook creates hidden profiles for people who haven’t joined the network, which Facebook says it doesn’t do.

Facebook absolutely does, but can get away with claiming that it doesn't since it is a little different from the "profile" you create when you sign up. This makes your experience more personal and amazing as soon as you do sign up, among other "benefits" (in quotation marks because cui bono?). They also need it for their ad network. LinkedIn's builds its shadow profiles even more aggressively.

> Can't users who don't use facebook file a restraining order?

I doubt you could prove standing in the US (it would be difficult to claim "harm" in the US's legal sense of the word). In Europe you'd have a pretty good shot, though I haven't seen anyone try this tack yet. But Max Schrems' successful suit would be an excellent precedent for anyone who wanted to try.

BTW I like FB, though I haven't been on in weeks.


> In Europe you'd have a pretty good shot, though I haven't seen anyone try this tack yet.

Since (as best I know) the GDPR requires positive informed recorded consent for a company to hold your personal data, Facebook would almost certainly be in direct contravention of this if they hold any personal data on people who haven't joined.

Which is going to be fun because the fines are steep (well into the $Ms for each incident.)


Legislation is required. Call your representatives!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: