Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To be contrarian, I wonder if anyone's attempted to quantify the number of lives saved by the automotive transportation network. Ambulances seem like the most obvious case, wonder what others are out there.


Not only the lives directly saved as in the ambulance example, but indirectly saved by making better, fresher food available, by removing tons of horse feces from the streets, and generally improving quality of life by fueling a huge amount of economic activity that wouldn't be possible otherwise.


My father grew up during the transition from horse to car, and he said people have forgotten about how dangerous horses are - they killed a lot more people (relatively speaking) than cars do.

Just cleaning up the daily harvest of dead horses was a major operation in every city.


Take a look at what the car replaced. Horses were and are wildly dangerous.


In fact, ISTR that a key part of old stories is folks accidentally trampled by horses.

That doesn't say anything about which is worse: horses or cars. I wonder if any study has been done about that. It'd have to be complex, e.g. covering sicknesses from manure, sicknesses from leaded gasoline, sicknesses from pollution &c.


Original roadways were lobbied for and paid by cyclists.

There's no chance that humans would go back to carriages as a realistic transport method. Shouldn't we be comparing against electric bicycles and public transport networks?

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2011/aug/1...


Try hauling goods by bicycle. We cannot replace evey road with a rail.


Totally valid. And yet imagine how much more effectively emergency responders could operate if they didn't need to compete with the general public given there were better alternate transport modes.


From those I have seen people are really good at getting out of the way from emergency drivers, so they mostly don't.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: