Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Could this be used to fund Universal Basic Income? A starter is looking at the wealth fund in Norway or citizen dividends in Alaska.



Not really. Unless you get efficiency gains, all the income from the government charging itself rent gets eaten up as expenses for paying itself rent. Basically what it's doing is making imputed rent an explicit budget item, and then allowing financial ~stuff~ to be done with those budget items explicitly (say, letting a department save money by using real estate more efficiently).


My interpretation was they charge other people rent for the services, no?


Not at first. It's fixing an accounting rule that draws distinctions between equivalent cash-flow situations.

A: City owns an office building with a $1MM/yr fair-market rent, which it uses for administration.

B: City collects $1MM/yr rent from their office building, and pays $1MM/yr to rent out a different building for their administration to use.

If you net out the imputed rent in situation A, then it looks like the administration is $1MM/yr cheaper than it actually is.


Ahh - got it. Thanks!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: