Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Young American Men Are Choosing Video Games Over Work in Staggering Numbers (fortune.com)
2 points by drfuchs on July 17, 2017 | hide | past | favorite | 2 comments



I've seen this cited so many times I had to dig into the root paper [1] The entirety is going to require some reading after work, is quite lengthy, but from a brief skimming I'm far from convinced that they're not inverting causation, and even if they aren't, they phrase their conclusion FAR more gently than TFA, leading to an interpretation that I find far more in congruence with reality: That there has been a confluence of games being better with real life propositions being worse for the demographic brackets in question. Even preparing for college and work 20~ years ago was an abysmal experience for me, and with the world as it is now, I don't know how I'd have found the motivation if I needed to do it again. And then you're posed with the alternative of a beautiful escapism, a world in which you have power, autonomy, a job you enjoy, and can work towards a better life? At the risk of waxing philosophical, if you want to make people play less video games, don't blame the video games; that's paramount to the mistakes we made back in prohibition. Focus on making the world for these people a better place so they don't need a respite from it.

[1] http://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/maguiar/fil...


A behavior will not typically be modified until the alternative is more appealing. It is not as simple to connect behavior to cause as this study implies without limiting outside factors.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: