Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Glad I am not the only one who only had "finally I get to see what they mean - oops the 100ms timeslot is over" moments watching this video.


That seems to be the trend in videos these days. It drives me crazy when they show a car and it's 0.2s in a tunnel, 0.3s on a mountain and so on. You can watch a whole video and still don't known it looks. But together with music and sound effects it's cool.


Explanatory videos come in a few flavors, many of them bad:

- Blipverts, like this one. Pretty, but useless. Typical use: Ads, Kickstarter videos.

- Talking heads with PowerPoint. Boring. Typical use: online courses, TED talks.

- Long single-shot videos of someone doing something complicated. Boring, but useful. Typical use: how-to videos.

- History Channel style. Video of important stuff with occasional interpretive graphics and explanation. Tough to balance but can be done well. Expensive to produce. Tends to oversimplify.

- Classic industrial film. See anything from the Jam Handy Organization. The Internet Archive has hundreds of these films. Good at getting concepts across. Blah by modern standards. Narrated, but not much talking head time. Minimal animation of details. Many stock shots.

That field needs some design work. If the goal is to explain (not sell), the industrial film model, modernized, has potential. It takes more production effort than a blipvert or a PowerPoint video, but less than a History Channel video.

Top of the line in explanatory videos: "Victory through Air Power" (1943) [1] This was made by Disney for one purpose - to convince President Roosevelt to go with heavy land-based bombers as the main weapon in the Pacific war.

[1] https://archive.org/details/VictoryThroughAirPower


Classic Jam Handy: "Around the Corner", which explains how an automobile differential works.[1] (Skip the first three minutes.) If you watch this, you will understand how a differential works, and won't forget it. An explanation of Microsoft's new UI with similar clarity would be helpful.

[1] https://archive.org/details/Aroundth1937


Thanks for that. I'm the opposite of a "car guy," but that was a highlight of my day.


There's a whole series of those films, all done for Chevrolet.

- "What Stops Them" - hydraulic brakes

- "Tough Friends" - automotive steel alloys

- "No Ghosts" - auto frame design for stiffness

- "Horsepower" - shows exactly what one horsepower is

- "Balance" - system integration of the automobile

- "Precisely so" - measurement and manufacturing precision

- "Streamlines" - air resistance

- "Down the gasoline trail" - from fuel tank to exhaust

All these are in the Internet Archive in the Prelinger collection of industrial films.

Chevrolet really wanted to explain how an automobile works. These films are much better at explaining than most of what we see today.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: