Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Capitalism requires a complete and total separation of state from economics"

How do you fund the state, which is required for the provision of certain public goods like the common defense and that in most libertarian schemes enforces contracts?

Also, modern societies cede a monopoly on the legitimate use of force outside of self-defense to the state, which prevents revenge cycles (vendetta) and allows trust beyond families and clans.

The US and Japan are high trust societies and that makes a big difference in being able to do business (contract enforcement is a last and generally unsatisfactory resort) and all sorts of things we think as good. I think among other things that needs a state of more than minimal strength.



"How do you fund the state...?"

The government should sell optional contract insurance, which gives the contractual parties the right to go to court (or perhaps expedited enforcement in court) if the contract is not met. The rate should be capped at some small percentage of the contract's value - say 1%.

But the exact method doesn't really matter; in a society that such as the one I am speaking of, surely there will be many who will see the obvious selfish gain in maintaining a limited government that it totally dedicated to the defense of their individual rights.


Actually, I don't think taxes would necessarily violate a separation, if the taxes were not attempting to manipulate the economy by favoring this or punishing that. A single-rate income tax, sales taxes, property taxes, and the like could effectively be "economy-neutral", that is neither benefiting some unfairly nor being an excessive drag. The big problem is with government regulation.


Perhaps in theory possible, but it violates the simple "complete and total separation of state from economics" principle.

And the public choice theory says it's not possible: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice_theory




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: