On: To Paul Graham

[gte910h]

" I might be more tempted to null or downvote the original point if the second one is better"

Can't both comments be good?

[paulgb → gte910h]

Agreed. I upvote contradictory comments all the time. I don't see it as lacking consistency; I'm voting for quality and thought, not necessarily "right" opinions.

[dhimes → paulgb]

I'm voting for quality and thought, not necessarily "right" opinions

Then you are doing it right.

[TheSOB88 → gte910h]

I almost wanted to upvote this, but I might have regretted it, so I didn't.