Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I mean I largely agree with you so I'm not sure what the issue is.

With regards to unemployment going down, it is (like the Single Market) a complex issue. There's economic growth yeah, but we've also just had 5+ years of net emigration too, with foreign nationals leaving and ex-pats returning (in my country, I should say).

These changes are obvious on the ground, I feel. Anecdotally, the shift in demographics of public-facing service workers in my country has been stunning in the last 15 years. It's gone from almost all indigenous, to almost all Eastern European, to almost all indigenous again. I'd be surprised if you hadn't noticed this in your own country?



> I mean I largely agree with you so I'm not sure what the issue is.

I called you out on your misinformation about FoM, that's all. I'm pretty sure we agree on the US topic :)

> With regards to unemployment going down, it is (like the Single Market) a complex issue. There's economic growth yeah, but we've also just had 5+ years of net emigration too, with foreign nationals leaving and ex-pats returning (in my country, I should say).

Again, you're trying to avoid looking at the numbers. Unemployment is in good numbers and good trends. "The economy" goes well, too - but one thing is not always the other.

> These changes are obvious on the ground, I feel. Anecdotally, the shift in demographics of public-facing service workers in my country has been stunning in the last 15 years. It's gone from almost all indigenous, to almost all Eastern European, to almost all indigenous again.

So that's your issue? the nationality of the workers you see?

If unemployment is almost only structural (very low %) - the nationality of those on employment is hardly relevant. Now if you had a 10% and all of them were locals, something must be wrong. That's not the case though.

> I'd be surprised if you hadn't noticed this in your own country?

I usually don't ask the nationality of random people :) and I work in a very international industry, so my views might be very skewed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: