Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If we are receiving the FRBs, the focused beam must be pointed towards earth. So the spaceships with light sails must be headed in the direction of earth. Get ready for the invasion!



I think the beam spreads a lot because

1. the wavelength is relatively long, because you want a sparse microwave sail

2. the antenna is of finite size

3. the distance involved is intergalactic


I for one welcome our new lightsail-powered overlords.


No because they are only short bursts. If they were guiding a spaceship in our direction then we would observe them as a constant source of light.


Only if they were aiming at where we are now, which doesn't make sense. They would have to aim the craft at where we are going to be in X years. X being the duration of the voyage.

Come to think of it, even if they were aiming directly at where we are now I would assume the light source would still be occulted regularly by everything between us and them.


They could be checking for stellar drift.


Gotta remember, if we are seeing light intentionally or unintentionally, they pointed these sails to our current position, almost X years in the past. Where X is the distance in light-years.


Well that's silly. How do they plan to decelerate?


You have two sails in concentric rings that are connected, with your craft attached to the outer ring. When you want to decelerate you disconnect the two rings and and tweak the reflection of the inner ring to be somewhat outward focused and give the inner ring a little push. As it moves forward the energy bouncing off the inner ring is directed backwards to the outer ring, which slows. As long as the inner ring reflect more energy backwards (and to the outer ring) than the outer ring is getting from your source the outer ring slows down. Really hard to describe, but easy to draw. First proposed by Robert L. Forward.


Images here: http://www.lunarsail.com/LightSail/rit-1.pdf (pages 5, 7 and 8).


If you project a large magnetic field the extra-solar ionized gas (intergalatic, between stars) can exert a fair amount of drag.

A lot of people talk about bussard collector (magnetic scope for hydrogen/helium) to power fusion. But instead of collecting gas use it as a drag chute.


Why do you think its "man"ed?

It could be an intra(inter)-galactic ballistic missile (i.e. no deceleration);


Shades of Larry Niven.


Protectors or Kzin? Either way, we're done.


Well, it'll take them awhile to get here. There's still time to start putting rail-guns on asteroids for purely mining purposes, or giant laser arrays on Mercury - just for moving ships around of course.


Moties, he's thinking of, as in "The Mote in God's Eye".


Or the FRBs are built using the least efficient beam design ever constructed ;)


Or reflecting off the sail. Or diffracting around it.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: