Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Thomas Schelling, New Nobel Laureate (2005) (marginalrevolution.com)
44 points by Hooke on Dec 15, 2016 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



I was fascinated by the idea of "Schelling Points" a few years back and made a sort of reality show demo based on it. Full disclosure, Mr Schelling agreed to watch the video at one point and was extremely gracious, but clearly not impressed. So I think it is safe to say the video does not well represent his ideas.

Regardless: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QU0WKM96eLM


I imagine Schelling saw much larger applications to this idea, where the finding people in a city was only a throwaway example for him. (For example, he talks about how it provides a basis for relatively stable agreements between groups that are at war with each other.) But it's a memorable one, and your video looked like a really fun project! It would be interesting to repeat this periodically and see how different teams do.

I enjoyed the team walking right past the other team's sign, and the clip of the knife juggler.

Edit: it's interesting that the teams in your experiment didn't exactly pursue the kind of strategy that Schelling suggested (which is basically to meet in the most "obvious" place at the most "obvious" time: maybe the city's best-known landmark at noon?). In Schelling's version of the scenario, the people trying to meet weren't necessarily allowed to write each other messages or ask strangers for help, just to decide on a (single?) time and place. With that restriction, there would be a stronger motivation to think harder about what appears "obvious". But they were still relatively successful with the approach of going to some of the most famous landmarks like Faneuil Hall, which both teams ultimately thought of.


I'm always -- well, occasionally -- pointing developers on my team to the Schelling Point Wikipedia article[0] because it's a concept that seems fundamental to developing maintainable code -- perhaps maintainable anything.

The basic question is: where do I put this information that I -- or another perhaps entirely new developer -- will likely need at some indeterminate point in the future so that he or she will be able to locate it as quickly and effortlessly as possible?

Some possible answers: README, docs, knowledge base, a variable name, a test, a code comment here, a code comment there, email the team, tell a co-worker, etc...

Ultimately, I guess the answer comes down to a set of cultural habits and practices grounded in some assumptions about human nature.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Focal_point_(game_theory)


FWIW, I took a crack at what some obvious focal points might be a while back.

http://bitmason.blogspot.com/2015/03/focal-points-culture-an...

It's worth noting that knowing any shared context between groups trying to find each other is important. In the original Grand Central clock example, the subjects were Yale students, so Grand Central was a pretty obvious meeting place--it's where the trains from New Haven arrive in the city. And you don't even have to know Grand Central to immediately realize the clock/information booth is where'd you meet someone.


I'd definitely have put City Hall as the obvious meetup point in Philadelphia. All the subway and trolley lines meet there, it's visually central in the city and has a pretty obvious "center" spot in the middle of the courtyard where you'd see someone. Though if I had to meet out-of-towners, the liberty bell would be a solid choice, too.


As I say, although I grew up about an hour west, there are probably at least a dozen cities in the US I know better than Philly :-) Not sure if I've ever even been to City Hall.

Again, it does come back to the context though.


Adam Curtis created a documentary that features interviews with Thomas Schelling and others quite a bit; talking about MAD and the nuclear strategy of the US during the cold war. The whole series is incredible IMO but part 2 is probably the best of them.

Pandora's Box "To the Brink of Eternity" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TRHcNDYpFU


I started looking into Schelling after seeing this post, and had some difficulty locating a sample of his work (broken links all over for some reason). Eventually I came across his Tanner lecture "Ethics, Law, and the Exercise of Self-Command"—which is very interesting and amusing: http://tannerlectures.utah.edu/_documents/a-to-z/s/schelling...




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: