Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Alcohol certainly contributes to depression. It also causes a great deal of social harm. If you heatmap crime in a city bars are often the epicenters of violent crime. Factor in that the majority of sexual assaults and domestic abuse cases involve alcohol and I'm not sure what your argument is.


Alcohol contributes to depression in excess, in small regular quantities what harm is there?

> If you heatmap crime...

Again, look at all the problems I had with your original arguments. Alcohol is legal, and hence there is far more opportunity to abuse it. Small, regular amounts of alcohol is likely not be be harmful at all - all problems arise from excess, hence there is an argument for restriction, not criminalization.

Why are you talking about alcohol rather than marijuana in any case? Your comparison is a straw-man - whatever can be concluded about alcohol doesn't necessarily apply to marijuana.


Why are you talking about alcohol rather than marijuana in any case?

Your assertion was that legalizing cannabis would cause social harm. If your goal is preventing harm then you must also criminalise the currently legal recreational drugs to be logically consistent.


> then you must also criminalise

No you don't, did you read what I wrote!


Drug that does objectively more damage = legal

Drug that does objectively less damage = illegal, it is too damaging

You have a right to an opinion, but logic is not open to interpretation.


> logic is not open to interpretation.

It is; you are just making up rules and calling them "logic". These are just your arguments, and they are flawed and inconclusive.

Again, read my comments, I'm not interested in your comparisons if you don't even answer to the problems with your own arguments.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: