Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Salary ranges on job listings benefit employers not employees.

Effectively; Salary is what the company values your contribution at. That's why when you hand your notice in you might be offered a pay rise.

By setting a public range you agree informally to be constrained by that range; asking for more once you've interviewed is harder.

Without salary range it is the opportunity that interests you. It lets you set expectations in the first (or later) conversation. Effectively giving you more power in the negotiation.

As an aside; always bid a tad high (for obvious reasons).




>Salary ranges on job listings benefit employers not employees.

I guess that's why most companies in the US don't list salaries, out of the goodness of their hearts.

Ranges on jobs benefit employees. It's simple negotiation. You want the other person to put out the first number. If the employer is thinking $100K for a position, but a qualified candidate starts with $80K, they just saved $20K a year. If they put $100K, they started first, so an employee who would have taken $80K now gets $100K.

As a side note, all IT people should watch Pawn Stars, American Pickers or any reality show that is part negotiation. It will give you a feel of small things to help negotiate. If all IT people learned to negotiate better, everyone's salaries would go up.


I've been on both sides of this, as employer and employee.

Salaries are arbitrary; it is what an employer values you as an employee, and what you value yourself at.

The best time to talk about salaries is when the company has offered you the role. Before then you have limited power. The reason companies set salary ranges is to frame the conversation on their terms.

> If they put $100K, they started first, so an employee who would have taken $80K now gets $100K.

This broadly assumes companies are not able to appropriately understand market salaries. I've never found this to be the case (certainly in large companies).

Large companies will have a salary range. But they will definitely also not want to publish them, for hopefully obvious reasons ("what do you mean my job title is on the market for $10K more??"). Its the same reason your contract probably says something about not revealing salary/renumeration.

I stand by my thesis; jobs with salary ranges I've always had more trouble negotiating. Where jobs without salary ranges I've found myself earning 10-15% more than peers. I'd argue the problem is that employees undervalue themselves and are risk averse in negotiating ("If I ask too much they will not hire me").




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: