Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Then what are you in agreement with in Kernighan's assessment of Pascal? His assessment may have made sense 35 years ago but is out of date today.


Even 35 years ago it didn't make much sense, because he deliberately ignored the Pascal dialects that didn't had those set of issues.

Also C outside UNIX was just a mix of K&R C dialects, each with its own set of quirks and as portable across compiler vendors, as those Pascal dialects.


C inside of unix, which is probably the world Brian was coming from, didn't have those problems. And he had a point about the lack of unification. As to ignoring the dialects lacking that set of issues, I don't see how so. He explicitly stated that various dialects had solved the problems he discussed, but noted that such solutions were non-portable.

So I still consider it a valid assessment of the language he assessed. But I also acknowledge that Pascal is no longer that language.


...Which was the point I was trying to make. I am in agreement with Kernighan's assessment of the language he assessed. This is not the same language that Pascal is today.

This was probably confusing. I am sorry.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: