Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I may know a friend who torrented a film they had on DVD because their DVD player broke and it was faster and cheaper than ripping it themselves.

This is a tort again in the UK, it wasn't then.

Also, most people would be happy to pay the actors and crew a very healthy wage but baulk at paying to add DRM and several layers of executives whose function appears to be to make it as hard as possible to actually watch the content without paying again and again and who extract far more than their share of the revenue.

I actually looked for a download of that DVD (for my friend!) but none was available. The family in question used a hacked Wii to watch DVDs, but the DRM prevented half of them from working.

Meanwhile we watched a show on YouTube other day, we could have watched it on "watch again" but the content quality was immeasurably better. Of course that too was a tort akin to torrenting.



>Also, most people would be happy to pay the actors and crew a very healthy wage but baulk at paying to add DRM and several layers of executives whose function appears to be to make it as hard as possible to actually watch the content without paying again and again and who extract far more than their share of the revenue.

Sure, all of the people torrenting are really just protesting as the unjust profits made by studio executives. This is laughable.

>The family in question used a hacked Wii to watch DVDs, but the DRM prevented half of them from working.

And a perfectly functional DVD player is like $20.

===============================

Rate-limited by HackerNews, but in response to the below:

===============================

>What's your second point? That just because it only costs a week's groceries to buy a DVD player it was wrong to torrent a work that has been paid for and only can't be consumed due to DRM? Do you find that use immoral?

Copyright becomes unenforceable if you can just go buy a physical DVD with cash whenever you get sued or warned for pirating something.


First point taken, I overstretched.

What's your second point? That just because it only costs a week's groceries to buy a DVD player it was wrong to torrent a work that has been paid for and only can't be consumed due to DRM? Do you find that use immoral?




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: