Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is anyone else troubled by the fact that these psychological studies, once you've been exposed to them, seem indispensable to everyday life, but you just can't get used to the idea of actually studying them much?

Maybe it's just the clinical or analytical nature of formal psychology that makes it hard to swallow. Perhaps reading the Proverbs or other sage literature dispenses the same helpful advice, but without the clinical self-awareness.

And, aren't psychologists the ultimate sociopaths, distorting the metaphysics or their surroundings?



Speaking as a former psych major, I don't think there's any real psychology behind his writing, aside from the basic concept of a sociopath. His writing is closer to philosophy or pop psychology, and there is nothing clinical or formal about it...

> And, aren't psychologists the ultimate sociopaths, distorting the metaphysics or their surroundings?

No. Writing a paper about SQL injection attacks is much different than using a SQL injection attack to grab credit card numbers.


there is nothing clinical or formal about it

But do you think he's wrong? and if so, where?


I don't think my psych major qualifies me to say that any more than anyone else.


It's one of those essays that sounds deep, but I am questioning exactly how deep it really is. Oh well, I am still questioning then.


It's another prism. Add it to your toolkit, apply, observe. Don't ever settle for just one, though.


Exactly. His ideas aren't science, even social science.

His philosophy is a prism--like analyzing a story in terms of Jungian archetypes, or a picture in terms of phallic imagery. There isn't a falsifiable theory in there anywhere. Yes this applies to Freud too, which is why his ideas have largely been discredited and ignored in mainstream psychology for years.


Come on... do you think the theory holds ground?


I don't think the author makes a claim that he is a psychologist, he refers himself as pop psychologist,probably jokingly

From the article:

  The term arrested development is now deprecated by
  professional psychologists and has been replaced by 
  developmentally disabled.This is good news for <b>us pop 
  psychologists</b> hawking crude over-simplifications about
  functional adults, since we can safely steal the term.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: