On long trips, especially coming home from long trips, I'm usually in at least a little bit of a hurry to get there and be done driving. It's therefore worth $1.50 (assuming I pay $.10 per gallon more than is necessary for my 15 gallon tank) to me to only have to fill up once. In practice, I've found the price aren't usually even that much, so the time saved is that much better of a deal.
But the time saved adds up at the same pace, as well. If spending $1.50 to save 10 minutes is worth it in each invidual case, in aggregate it's worth it as well.