Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

if you examine the frame between 2:40 and 2:41

I don't think people do that in combat. If you're ever in combat, or in a situation with armed people who think you may want to kill them, I highly recommend that you make it very obvious you're not armed. If they look at the footage of how you died and say "Oh! If we examine the frame, it looks like he wasn't going to kill us, after all!" I guess you'll be vindicated.




In the military investigation, it is revealed that the man crouching around the corner with the camera was taking a picture of US troops 100 meters away. The timestamped photo was found on the camera later.

So he's in an area where combat has occurred, crouching around a corner, pointing a long tube at US troops. No press is suspected to be in the area. Other men in his group are undeniably armed with weapons. He's a threat by any reasonable standard.

Two RPGs are, in fact, found at the site by ground forces, as is an automatic rifle. There were combatants in this group.


Uh, wtf. The helo is just circling about casually and they're taking their time fixing the targets before firing. How is that combat and an adrenaline rush moment? And that RPG...clearly a telephoto lens. Those supposed AKs look nothing like actual AKs.

I expect a well-trained pilot or soldier to be able to take a second to make sure they're firing on an actual target. If you look at the length of the damned video, you see that the helo pilots had enough time to examine the targets carefully (meaning at least a 10sec glance).


The response was directed to the blogger and his writing, who was not the same person as apache pilot to my knowledge, and therefore had the luxury of examining the video.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: