Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Fool's gold rush: Blockchain initiatives for everybody. Especially the artists (rocknerd.co.uk)
2 points by davidgerard on Sept 1, 2016 | hide | past | favorite | 3 comments


Dear everyone using the word "blockchain", whether working with one or writing about it: for the love of all that is holy, take five minutes out to do a Google search and at least read and understand the top hit or two before jumping on the bandwagon.

A blockchain is not the same thing as the Bitcoin distributed ledger implementation. The concept of an append-only chain of blocks of data linked by hashes is one small component of Bitcoin, and your own application need not be constrained by all the other design decisions Bitcoin has taken just because it happens to use a blockchain.

Specifically, Bitcoin may choose to use a proof-of-work competition to impose an ordering on its distributed ledger, but there is nothing about the blockchain concept itself that forces you to do the same thing.

The field of network synchronisation has been well studied since the 70s and many alternative solutions exist; almost all non-Bitcoin applications have more relaxed requirements for anonymity, peer trust, consensus and decentralisation, so there is rarely good reason to pick a solution that "uses about the power output of Ireland".


Seems quite rambling and doesn't get to the point. I think they are trying to say that Blockchain based music sales are a non starter and I agree. We are moving away from the people paying for prerecorded music paradigm and everyone wants to be at the start of the next wave of charging for music, whatever that may be.


OP here. Yeah, not as clear as I'd have liked.

I was struck by finding no less than five different initiatives all claiming to do music rights on "Blockchain", all using the same buzzwords and all making no sense at all. The intended audience was musicians and music fans curious about the hype.

I thought I made my point by the end - "stay away" :-)




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: