Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Your comment contains theory and pop psychology popular in the West.

It does contain theory, but it doesn't contain psychology or anything "pop". It's anthropology and evolutionary biology. My views also aren't popular among Western people, except those who like to scientifically pick apart the origins of beloved social traditions. This makes most people uncomfortable.

> many Eastern cultures do not view mating or courtship in the same way

That's nice. Do you actually know anything about "Eastern" views on courtship rituals, or are you just saying that my views aren't mystical enough and you assume that "Eastern" people have some sort of mystical interpretation?

The fact that you're appealing to cultural folklore about dating at all should cause you to re-consider your argument.



>It does contain theory, but it doesn't contain psychology or anything "pop". It's anthropology and evolutionary biology

At the very pop level. No anthropologist or biologist would make as crude presentations of the relevant arguments -- or even think their interaction with culture is some solved problem and it's 100% "evolution" at play.

>My views also aren't popular among Western people, except those who like to scientifically pick apart the origins of beloved social traditions. This makes most people uncomfortable.

No, it's mostly the crude early 20th century scientism and basic oversight of empirical data.

>The fact that you're appealing to cultural folklore about dating at all should cause you to re-consider your argument.

Well, your whole premise was that evolution trumps "cultural folklore" and customs, to which the parent's reference is completely justified as a counter-example.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: