You still have to then AND the output of that decoder with the data lines which go to the registers right? OP's friend just mentioned 1 extra gate in the data path, and I presume this would be it.
Yep, but a 7-input AND gate will have basically the same delay time as an 8-input AND gate. They don't scale linearly as it would if you stacked 6 or 7 gates in series (although that's typically how you do it in math or programming)
Oh of course yeah. I was picturing it as a separate AND when it could be bunged in with the ANDs for individual register selects and write/load enables and so on also. Cool, thanks.