Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

? you expect them to GPL a triple A game engine?



Yes. Why not?


Because they've spent tons of money on it and now want to earn something


>implying nobody can make money while respecting user freedom

This has been debunked so many times I'm not going to bother.


Let me rephrase - why would they lose part of their money - much money? I can't see what would be their profit on releasing UE under open source license. Moreover, what would be profit of others except the right of copying their code?


> I can't see what would be their profit on releasing UE under open source license.

They have already forgone a lot of potential revenue by allowing anyone to get the source code for the engine (under a proprietary license) without paying anything. The only thing left is to design a non-royalty revenue model that can work with a free software license. This has already been solved.

> Moreover, what would be profit of others except the right of copying their code?

Being able to release free software games using UE. Creating a community around UE that allows for innovation by that community. Porting to new platforms by that community. A show of good will to the free software community. There are many good reasons, but they all come about from giving people software freedom.


> They have already forgone a lot of potential revenue by allowing anyone to get the source code for the engine (under a proprietary license) without paying anything.

They're making to pay only those who has profits from using their engine. Those who has no profits (i.e. less than $3000) wouldn't buy it anyway.

> Being able to release free software games using UE.

You can do that now.

> Creating a community around UE that allows for innovation by that community.

There is a community.

> Porting to new platforms by that community.

You can do that now.

> There are many good reasons, but they all come about from giving people software freedom.

I am for free software, but I don't like ideology in name of ideology.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: