Additional safety nets would be needed. A transition wouldn't likely happen overnight. It would more likely be a gradual phasing out of old programs and a build-up of basic income as money is moved toward that program. At the same time, additional resources would need to be pushed into services to help people budget and manage their finances. A combination of traditional in-person financial counseling and software would work best.
I use Simple, and they have a good model for integrating budgeting into their bank app. A basic income program should follow the same principles, giving out a debit card with a budget along with a website and app to help people manage their money better. The first expense it can cover is a cheap smartphone for those that need it.
Analytics tracking the efficiency of the program should allow a lot of optimizations over time. There's no way to predict exactly what will happen without trying it, but data on a national scale should make beneficial adjustments to things like budgeting software pretty easy.
A basic income is not a perfect and ideal system, but I'd say it's definitely an improvement over the status quo. It does require having some trust in people to manage their money, but with a little assistance, I think people will be able to make better choices for themselves than a bureaucracy can make for them.
It would more likely be a gradual phasing out of old programs and a build-up of basic income as money is moved toward that program
Yes, this has been my conclusion.
I don't think a BI will ever happen. But I suspect/hope that in maybe a couple hundred years, we'll have something very similar to it under a different name ... probably still with some level of admin overhead to deal with the "poor people make bad decisions" issue that has been raised.
The welfare state has expanded massively over time just due to the increase in life expectancy and health care cost inflation. But if we assume that these things reach some sort of natural peak, then eventually as GDP grows and more taxes become available, a progressively more generous welfare state should be the natural outcome ... at least for governments that have got their debt levels under control.
Unfortunately the looming pension deficits mean it'll probably be a long time before we reach such a happy state. Our society is very obviously not rich enough to handle even the current levels of welfare (or put another way, our society misallocates resources). There is no realistic chance of a BI any time soon.
I use Simple, and they have a good model for integrating budgeting into their bank app. A basic income program should follow the same principles, giving out a debit card with a budget along with a website and app to help people manage their money better. The first expense it can cover is a cheap smartphone for those that need it.
Analytics tracking the efficiency of the program should allow a lot of optimizations over time. There's no way to predict exactly what will happen without trying it, but data on a national scale should make beneficial adjustments to things like budgeting software pretty easy.
A basic income is not a perfect and ideal system, but I'd say it's definitely an improvement over the status quo. It does require having some trust in people to manage their money, but with a little assistance, I think people will be able to make better choices for themselves than a bureaucracy can make for them.